Friday, August 15, 2008

Guantanamo has to be shut down because it is a cancer in our relations with the world. It is much more than that, but because it exists, it is a constant reminder to the world of the new image that the United States has acquired since 9/11.
One may protest that torture does not take place there, prisoners are being released, and that terrorists are often tried in normal courts. This does not matter. When the French stormed the Bastille on July 14, 1789, they did not care that it no longer served the purpose of torturing the King's enemies by superceding the law and only had six prisoners in it. They only saw it as a symbol; a constant reminder of despotism. This reminder brought down Louis XVI and if we continue to disregard our standing in the world, we could find ourselves bereft of traditional allies.
I am a bit concerned today after reading an article in Aftenposten, a Norwegian newspaper, that quotes a Russian, Sergei Markov, accusing Dick Cheney of a conspiracy to start the Georgian war in order to get McCain elected. I am no friend of Cheney's and such a theory might not be that shocking if it came from a random Russian citizen. The problem here is that Sergei Markov is the head of the Moscow Institute for Political Studies! That's right, the head of a supposedly respectable, academic institution is spouting off conspiracy theories. I know that the university of Moscow had come under suspicion lately of un-academic anti-semitism but delving into improbably conspiracy theories to bolster the regime's image is a new low.

Tuesday, July 22, 2008

Master Status


This last summer I was introduced to the concept of 'master status'. I am no sociologist, but from what I understand of the concept, from all the different identities we possess--brother, sister, christian, parent, student, American, teenager, etc.--there seems to be one that rises to the top in our own view or in the view of others. Which master status rises to the top depends on surroundings and circumstances. For example, if an individual feels that one of their identities is persecuted by the majority, they will make that identity their 'master status.' This process comes about because of the individual and the majority. The majority sees what is different about others, and we try to differentiate ourselves from the majority.

This summer, I experienced this phenomenon in very stark terms. Emerging from almost two years at Brigham Young University where almost everyone is Mormon, I spent a few months in a small, medieval German town with students from all across the world, almost none of whom were religious. I found that all the Americans there knew readily that I was a Mormon as soon as I told them where I came from. My "mormonism" became my master status in their eyes immediately. In fact, "Mormon" became my name. This was mostly just amusing, but also somewhat frustrating because I did not see myself as just "Mormon." My environment at BYU possibly contributed to me trying to differentiate myself and view myself as a student of history, a young adult with a specific personality, etc. I was therefore frustrated when all that I was seen as was a "Mormon" with all my characteristics a priori thrust upon me.

Many observations could be made here about how we interact as human beings in terms of identity and stereotypes, especially in contrasting the way Americans viewed me as opposed to people from the rest of the world who did not know much about "Mormons." They definitely were intrigued by this aspect of my identity and we spoke much of it, but it was different in that their lack of knowledge automatically prevented them from stereotyping and they assumed a more understanding, curious attitude. Likewise, I spent most of my time with my non-American friends because they were also interested in my non-Mormon identities: American, student of History and German, young adult, etc. My one identity did not block out the others.

Monday, March 24, 2008

Objective

"Pour découvrir les meilleures règles de société qui conviennent aux nations, il faudrait une intelligence supérieure, qui vît toutes les passions des hommes et qui n'en éprouvât aucune, qui n'eût aucun rapport avec notre nature et qui la connût à fond, dont le bonheur fût indépendant de nous et qui pourtant voulût bien s'occuper du nôtre; enfin qui, dans le progrès des temps se ménageant une gloire éloignée, pût travailler dans un siècle et jouir dans un autre. Il faudrait des dieux pour donner des lois aux hommes."
(Discovering the rules of society best suited to nations would require a superior intelligence that beheld all the passions of men without feeling any of them; who had no affinity with our nature, yet knew it through and through; whose happiness was independent of us, yet who nevertheless was willing to concern itself with ours; finally, who, in the passage of time, procures for himself a distant glory, being able to labor in one age and find enjoyment in another. Gods would be needed to give men laws.) (Rousseau, Du Contrat Social)

I've thought a bit about this idea lately. Not exactly in the same context as Rousseau but in regard to how actually feeling something changes the way we look at something. I can expound philosophical truths about ideals all day long--and I hope that I would have the strength to stick with them--but somehow actually experiencing and feeling the real thing makes it clear just how hard it is to apply theory to reality. Rousseau says here that because man is not detached from emotion and passions, it is difficult to create a leader or society that is perfect.

Saturday, March 22, 2008

Conservative Circles


"In any animal I see nothing but an ingenious machine to which nature has given senses in order for it to renew its strength and to protect itself, to a certain point, from all that tends to destrou or disturb it. I am aware of precisely the same things in the human machine, with the difference that nature alone does everything in the operations of an animal, whereas man contributes, as a free agent, to his own operations. The former chooses or rejects by instinct and the latter by an act of freedom. Hence an animal cannot deviate from the rule that is prescribed to it, even when it would be advantageous to do so, while man deviates from it, often to his own detriment. Thus a pigeon would die of hunger near a bowl filled with choice meats, and so would a cat perched atop a pile of fruit or grain, even though both could nourish themselves quite well with the food they disdain, if they were of a mind to try some. And thus dissolute men abandon themselves to excesses which cause them fever and death, because the mind perverts the senses and because the will still speaks when nature is silent." (Rousseau, Discourse on the Origin of Inequality)

I thought this passage was extremely interesting. I see it as a common practice to extract examples from nature to prove a political/ideological point. Rousseau here is railing against the tendency of man to abandon his natural boundaries and thus become degenerate. Others might point to natural patterns of reproduction, assembly, government etc. to prove their point. To me, it is not always clear if one can use such comparisons as the basis of truth. I guess the question is to what extent are the patterns we find in nature supposed to serve as a model for what is right. There are surely many examples of things that happen in nature that we would reject as being moral.

Tuesday, March 18, 2008

Impressions

"Impressions always actuate the soul, and that in the highest degree; but it is not every idea which has the same effect. Nature has proceeded with caution in this case, and seems to have carefully avoided the inconveniences of two extremes. Did impression alone influence the will, we should every moment of our lives be subject to the greatest calamities; because, though we foresaw their approach, we should not be provided by nature with any principle of action, which might impel us to avoid them. On the other hand, did every idea influence our actions, our condition would not be much mended. For such is the unsteadiness and activity of thought, that the images of everything, especially of good s and evils, are always wandering in the mind; and were it moved by every idle conception of this kind, it would never enjoy a moment's peace and tranquility... Nature has therefore chosen a medium, and has neither bestowed on every idea of good and evil the power of actuating the will, nor yet has entirely excluded them from this influence. Thought and idle fiction has no efficacy, yet we find by experience that the ideas of those objects which we believe either are or will be existent produce in a lesser degree the same effect with those impressions, which are immediately present to the senses and perception. The effect, then, or belief is to raise up a simple idea to an equality with our impressions, and bestow on it a like influence on the passions."(DAVID HUME from Treatise of Human Nature)

This has always been very interesting to me. I noticed that thoughts, while having the possibility to be powerful by themselves, are greatly accentuated when accompanied by a physical impression. I remember experiencing certain things as a missionary that I had read about a thousand times that made sense but made no great impression on me, but when the experience took place, it was as if thunder struck. The thought became a brand on my mind and heart when coupled with experience. I know that Hume is saying a lot more here, but this is just what I think of first when reading this.

Thursday, March 13, 2008

People Movers



The way we humans try to legitimize things we do through categorization and names has always intrigued me. For example, there is this neighborhood by my house which has a big stone sign saying that the neighborhood is called "Venetian Villas" or something to that effect. Looking past the fact that the neighborhood is actually located in the Western U.S.--Orem, Utah to be exact--one can ask why we would feel this impulse to "borrow" the Venetian heritage.
What was my surprise then, when, traveling for the first time to the great state of Alaska, I meet this phenomenon, but going in the opposite direction. I had just hopped off my flight from Seattle to Anchorage with my traveling companion Andrew Christensen, and, having a few hours before our flight to Fairbanks, we decided that we wanted to see downtown Anchorage. We approached a friendly-looking police officer directing traffic and asked him if he knew where the buses to downtown Anchorage were. He looked at us kind of puzzled for a second and replied, "Oh, you mean the people mover. It is right over there." After recovering from this perplexing response, we proceeded to the before-mentioned location and we awaited the "people mover." Unfortunately we did not get to utilize the "people mover" due to time constraints, but we did consider taking a "personal people mover" (taxi), but eventually we decided on staying at the airport and eating before getting on the "flying people mover" to Fairbanks.
So basically I didn't realize that the great post-modernist movement has found a state that is committed to applying its principles in everyday life. We surely can't avoid categorizing, but we can simplify and render harmless our classifications as the Alaskans are finding out with their "people movers" (unless you are an Alaskan caribou who is left out of the picture with 'people' being in the title).